Newsweek sparked a conflagration among conservative
Christians last week by pointing out that Christian dating site
BigChurch.com is owned by Penthouse Media Group.
This wouldn't have been big news to BigChurch members who bothered to look under the site's hood. The Christian dating site
has been operated by social networking giant Various, Inc. (which runs
AdultFriendFinder.com, Bondage.com and Penthouse.com) for years.
Penthouse Media Group acquired BigChurch, along with dozens of other
niche social networking sites, when it purchased Various last December.
As a result of the purchase, Penthouse is now just one brand among
many in a corporation that focuses on social networking, says Penthouse
Media Group CEO Marc Bell.
Some people still think of Penthouse as Playboy's dirty cousin, even though Penthouse changed hands in 2004 and is now trying to be one step raunchier than Maxim rather than one step classier than Anal Sluts 13.
But when an old-guard porn kingpin like Penthouse
becomes just another niche, you know that times have changed. This
focus on social networking supports my ongoing argument that the
fantasy of porn will continue to yield to the fantasy of sex, and that savvy adult companies will keep up with these changing consumer expectations.
I also think the fantasy of sex, served by both mainstream dating sites
and adult social networks, will open our wallets in ways online porn
hasn't for years.
Of course, social media does not guarantee sex any more than porn
does. But it provides the anticipation of sex, the possibility of sex,
the idea that you just might get lucky. It's the premise of porn, manifested in reality. Almost.
Social networking promises a new experience each time. And free porn
can only be an advantage in an adults-only social networking context.
Just ask YouPorn.
If customers find themselves flirting and even cybering on a regular
basis, they return again and again, paying for premium memberships
until disillusionment sets in (why am I not getting laid for real?). Those who hook up in person remain members as long as the nookie is more fun than the drama.
Old-style softcore simply can't compete with that. Not because we don't
like to look at it, but because we don't like to pay for it --
especially when we can see the same thing on the social networking
sites while chatting with the women in the pictures.
It's not like BigChurch isn't about sex. It's just more subtle than
a site that's explicitly aimed at swingers. BigChurch's function is to
connect people whose concepts of sex are tied so closely to faith and
doctrine that it can be difficult to meet potential partners in more
traditional settings.
Many people who identify as Christians have a fairly secular
attitude toward premarital sex, while others believe in sexual pleasure
within marriage. A handful still relegate sex to procreation, and God
forbid that you (or at least, she) enjoy it.
With all this variation, it's possible that Christians benefit more
from online dating than even kinky people do, in that they don't waste
as much time chatting up people who don't share their particular
beliefs. After all, with an online matchmaker, it's just a matter of
checking the right boxes.
Whether BigChurch can survive the public link to Penthouse Media
Group remains to be seen. I'm not sure Penthouse would miss BigChurch
if a membership exodus killed the Christian dating site. BigChurch says
it has a mere half-million members, while AdultFriendFinder alone
claims about 24 million.
Even selling BigChurch might be a challenge now, as the URL will
carry the taint of blatant sexuality, unless whoever buys it can pull
off a "saving BigChurch from the devil" marketing campaign.
Given that Penthouse Media Group owns
all of the FriendFinder and Spring Street Networks sites, as well as
the legendary Danni.com and several webcam networks, it's hard to see
how losing one small property would make much of a dent.
It's the corporate version of the Question of Our Age: "What if my
day job learns about my sex blog?" Only this time, sex will win, either
way.
See you in a fortnight,
Regina Lynn
Regina Lynn shows you how to have more fun with sex in her new book, Sexier Sex: Lessons From the Brave New Sexual Frontier
, available now.